How Frederick the Great’s Sword Helped Spark the Civil War

This is not Frederick the Great's sword, but a Civil War era Klingenthal sword.

This is not Frederick the Great’s sword, but a Civil War era Klingenthal sword.

More than any other event, it was John Brown’s raid on Harpers Ferry that lit the fuse of North-South tension and ignited the Civil War. Brown planned the raid for two years in advance, so it was no mistake that the first thing he did when he crossed into Virginia was to send a detachment to steal a sword and kidnap its owner. It wasn’t just any old sword. It was – purportedly – the sword of the Prussian monarch Frederick the Great.

Legend of the Sword

Frederick the Great

Frederick the Great (standing) before the Battle of Torgau (1791) by Bernhard Rode, public domain.

The story of why Frederick the Great’s sword fascinated John Brown is a story of the symbolism in the raid. And that symbolism helped establish Brown’s reputation as a martyr.

Lewis Washington

Lewis Washington, Library of Congress Prints & Photographs Division; public domain.

Brown’s preparations for the raid included sending an advance man, John Edwin Cook, as a spy. Cook moved to Harpers Ferry over a year in advance. He blended in well and even married a local girl. One interesting tidbit Cook passed on to Brown had to do with a sword once belonging to Frederick the Great and two pistols once belonging to General Lafayette. Col. Lewis W. Washington, the great-grandnephew of George Washington, had inherited them and lived only four miles from Harpers Ferry. Frederick the Great had reputedly sent the sword to Washington in 1780 with a note: “From the oldest General in the world to the Greatest.”

John Brown Steals Frederick the Great’s Sword

John Brown. LOC LC-USZ62-89569

John Brown, Library of Congress Prints & Photographs Division, public domain.

Brown’s raiders kidnapped Washington in the middle of the night and delivered him by carriage, along with the sword and pistols, to the U.S. armory in Harpers Ferry, now under John Brown’s command. Brown kept Washington hostage in the armory’s fire engine house and wore Frederick’s sword during the following standoff. Robert E. Lee, appointed to command the U.S. troops from Fr. Monroe present in Harpers Ferry, successfully recaptured the armory.

Harpers Ferry

View over the historical Civil War town of Harpers Ferry, a National Park owned town, by the confluence of the Potomac and Shenandoah rivers, by Steve Heap, Shutterstock.com

Brown was injured and captured. Carrying Frederick’s sword might have helped save his life. When a U.S. Army lieutenant tried to strike Brown with a saber, something under Brown’s shirt deflected the blow. That something is thought to be the buckle for the belt carrying the sword. Brown, according to one source, surrendered Frederick’s sword and Lafayette’s pistols to a black man, Osborn Perry Anderson, a freeborn Pennsylvanian who had joined Brown on the raid. They were eventually returned to Washington.

Had Brown been killed immediately, he may not have become a national martyr. His stoicism in face of the death penalty is one of the things that changed him, in the eyes of the North, from an abolitionist who had gone too far to a national saint.

Why the sword? And why the pistols?

The Sword in Symbolism

Lewis Washington as a captive in Harpers Ferry.

Harper’s Ferry insurrection – Interior of the Engine-House, just before the gate is broken down by the storming party – Col. Washington and his associates as captives, held by Brown as hostages. Library of Congress Prints & Photographs Division, 1859; public domain.

John Brown planned the raid on Harpers Ferry not only on a tactical level, but also a symbolic one. Symbolism was already reflected in his selection of the date for his raid: July 4, 1859. Only because he couldn’t amass enough men and materials by Independence Day did Brown postpone the raid to October 16.

George Washington & Lafayette at Valley Forge

Washington & Lafayette at Valley Forge, public domain.

Historians today doubt whether Frederick really gave Washington a sword. It’s impossible to determine the origins of the sword because it was severely damaged in a fire in 1911. But the point is moot, because the people of the era believed it really was Frederick the Great’s sword and the role it played was symbolic. Brown had planned from the beginning to place those national heirlooms in the hands of a black man as a symbol of racial justice.

Literature on point:

Michael Korda: Clouds of Glory: The Life and Legend of Robert E. Lee (Harper, 2014)

Peggy A. Russo & Paul Finkelman, eds. Terrible Swift Sword: The Legacy of John Brown (Athens, Ohio: Ohio University Press 2005)

United States Department of the Interior; National Park Service. National Registers of Historic Places Inventory – Nomination Form for Beall-Air (Jefferson County, West Virginia) 1973.

10 Comments

  1. Brian
    Mar 11, 2015

    Brown stole the sword from the North to protest slavery in the South?

    • Ann Marie
      Mar 11, 2015

      Brown stole the sword from the South. Lewis Washington lived in Harpers Ferry, so he was in Virginia.

  2. David Wilma
    Jan 3, 2016

    If Brown planned the raid two years in advance, he did a poor job. He chose an indefensible position in the engine house and did not proceed with taking arms to the rebellious slaves. In my opinion he planned to be a martyr and in so doing betrayed the men under his command. They were either killed in the raid or hanged later.

    The sword gets far more credit for the war than is supported by the evidence.

    • Ann Marie
      Jan 3, 2016

      The sword played a symbolic role, that’s true. But it’s interesting that Brown included it in his plans — one has to ask why.

      Your theory about Brown planning to be a martyr is intriguing. Thanks for commenting, David.

  3. Patrick Murphy
    Sep 4, 2016

    Actually, the troops Robert E. Lee was commanding included U.S. Marines that President Buchanan had sent from their barracks in Washington, D.C. The lieutenant who nearly felled brown was likewise a Marine: Israel Greene, who although a Northerner, would resign his commission at the onset of the Civil War and go on to serve in the Confederate Staes Marine Corps.

    • Ann Marie
      Sep 6, 2016

      That’s an interesting piece of history, Patrick. I didn’t know that. Thanks for commenting.

  4. Marilyn Tomlins
    Jan 3, 2017

    Very interesting.

  5. Augusta von Nassau
    Jan 4, 2017

    Robert E. Lee also brought an aide with him, who happened to be at the War Department when the event broke out: James Ewell Brown Stuart.

    • Ann Marie
      Jan 5, 2017

      That’s an interesting historical tidbit. So many players in the Civil War had a past that involved cooperation, sometimes with their future enemies. That makes the war so poignant.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. The Five Greatest Criminal Trials of History - […] the Great incorporated the ideal of the Declaration of Independence into European law (he was an admirer of George…
  2. Mary Todd Lincoln's Castle Ghost in Germany - […] the Prussian empress or two posts on Frederick the Great, a member of the Hohenzollern dynasty: How Frederick the…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Content is protected !!